How to Effectively Use Pathetic Fallacy in Creative Writing: Understanding the Literary Device and Its Impact
One of the most powerful tools available to writers is the ability to imbue the natural world with human emotion. In creative writing, this technique, known as pathetic fallacy, allows writers to evoke mood, foreshadow events, and enrich the thematic depth of their narratives. Derived from the Latin word pathos (meaning emotion or suffering) and the Greek word fallacy (meaning mistaken belief), pathetic fallacy involves ascribing human feelings or characteristics to non-human elements of nature. This literary device, which can be found across various genres and time periods, is not merely an aesthetic choice, but also an important narrative technique that shapes how readers interact with the text.
The concept of pathetic fallacy, its historical roots, and its role in creative writing, has a dramatic impact on storytelling. We will look at how writers can use it effectively, as well as potential pitfalls to avoid when employing this device.
What is Pathetic Fallacy?
At its core, pathetic fallacy is the attribution of human emotions to inanimate objects or nature, such as the weather, landscapes, or animals. It is a form of personification, but with a specific focus on projecting human feelings and emotional states onto the natural world. For example, if a character is sad, and the weather suddenly turns gloomy with rain or thunder, this is an instance of pathetic fallacy.
Consider the following example from Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights:
“The intense horror of nightmare came over me: I tried to move, but the hand clung to mine, and the thunder growled, and the lightning split the sky, as if nature herself was as enraged as I was.”
In this excerpt, the storm isn’t just described as happening in the background but is imbued with emotional intensity, mirroring the character’s inner turmoil. The thunder and lightning are presented as an extension of the character’s rage or fear, reinforcing the emotional atmosphere of the scene.
The technique often enhances the reader’s emotional engagement with the story, as it helps them to feel the same tension or sadness as the characters. It can also underline certain themes, such as the harmony or dissonance between human emotions and the larger forces of the world.
Historical Roots of Pathetic Fallacy
The concept of pathetic fallacy has its roots in both Romanticism and earlier literary traditions. The term itself was coined by the Victorian art critic John Ruskin in his work Modern Painters (1843). He used the term somewhat disparagingly to refer to the attribution of human feelings to nature, which he considered a form of artistic error or immaturity.
Despite its initially negative connotation, the technique has been used effectively by writers and poets throughout history, especially in the Romantic period. Romantic writers such as William Wordsworth, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, and John Keats often used the technique to reflect the deep emotional and spiritual connections between humans and nature. Nature was seen not only as a backdrop to human life but as an active participant in the emotional experiences of characters.
For example, in Wordsworth’s famous poem I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud, the daffodils that the speaker encounters are described as “dancing” and “fluttering,” which imbues the flowers with a sense of joy and life that corresponds to the speaker’s inner happiness:
“Ten thousand saw I at a glance,
Tossing their heads in sprightly dance.”
This type of depiction goes beyond simple description, creating a vivid and emotional connection between the natural world and the speaker’s mood. The daffodils seem almost alive, mirroring the speaker’s emotional response to their beauty.
While Ruskin criticised the technique, it is important to understand that the use of pathetic fallacy was not merely about “mistaking” the emotional qualities of nature, but about enhancing the emotional resonance of the writing. Nature became a powerful mirror, amplifying or reflecting human emotions in a way that deepened the reader’s engagement with the text.
The Role of Pathetic Fallacy in Creative Writing
Pathetic fallacy is not just a decorative or ornamental device—it serves several important functions in creative writing:
Setting the Tone and Mood: One of the primary functions of pathetic fallacy is to help set the tone or mood of a scene. The weather or natural environment can provide an immediate sense of emotional atmosphere, influencing how the reader feels about the events taking place. For instance, dark storm clouds and howling winds might suggest a sense of foreboding or impending doom, while a sunny, calm day could evoke a sense of peace or joy.
In Shakespeare’s Macbeth, the stormy weather and unnatural events that occur around Duncan’s murder serve to reflect the disruption of the natural order caused by Macbeth’s actions:
“The earth hath bubbles, as the water has,
And these are of them. Whither are they vanish’d?”
The tumultuous weather mirrors the chaos and moral confusion within the play. The use of pathetic fallacy here is a key narrative strategy that not only emphasises the emotional impact of the scene but also reinforces the play’s themes of guilt, corruption, and disorder.
Foreshadowing Events: Pathetic fallacy can also be used to foreshadow or hint at future events. A storm on the horizon, dark clouds gathering, or a sudden change in the weather can suggest impending conflict or tragedy. This creates a sense of anticipation, signalling to the reader that something significant is about to happen.
For example, in The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald uses the weather to mirror the progression of the novel’s tragic events. The hot, oppressive summer heat before Gatsby’s death mirrors the characters’ emotional tension, with the weather serving as a harbinger of the collapse of Gatsby’s dream:
“The air was thick with the heaviest, most oppressive heat, and the sun was beating down on the ground like a hammer.”
This use of pathetic fallacy creates an atmosphere of inevitability, where the weather seems to echo the unravelling of the characters’ lives.
Symbolism and Theme: Nature often functions as a symbol in literature, and pathetic fallacy can amplify these symbols by associating them with specific emotions or themes. A blooming flower might symbolise renewal or love, while a dying tree could represent decay or loss. When these symbols are infused with human emotions through pathetic fallacy, they become more vivid and meaningful.
In Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, the weather often reflects the novel’s themes of creation and destruction. The storm that accompanies Victor Frankenstein’s creation of the monster mirrors the monstrous act itself, as well as the darker aspects of human ambition and scientific hubris:
“It was on a dreary night of November that I beheld the accomplishment of my toils.”
In this case, the weather is not just a passive backdrop; it reinforces the gothic atmosphere and foreshadows the tragic consequences of Victor’s actions.
Characterisation: Pathetic fallacy can also be used to reflect a character’s emotions or psychological state. The external world often mirrors the internal world of the character, offering readers insights into a character’s mental or emotional state. In this way, nature acts as a reflection of a character’s inner turmoil, joy, or conflict.
In Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s The Yellow Wallpaper, the protagonist’s descent into madness is mirrored by the oppressive environment of her room, which seems to trap her just as much as her psychological state. The wallpaper itself becomes a symbol of her entrapment, and as her mental state deteriorates, so too does the environment around her:
“The pattern does move, and no wonder! The woman behind it shakes it!”
The pattern’s movements echo the character’s unravelling mind, creating a strong visual and emotional connection between the character’s state of mind and the environment around her.
How to Use Pathetic Fallacy Effectively
While pathetic fallacy can be a powerful tool, it is important to use it judiciously. Overuse or heavy-handed applications can make it seem contrived or forced, leading to a loss of its emotional impact. Here are some tips for using pathetic fallacy effectively:
1. Subtlety is Key: Instead of overtly stating that the weather reflects the character’s emotions, allow the mood to emerge naturally through description. For example, instead of saying “It was a gloomy day because she was sad,” describe the sky in a way that implies the emotional atmosphere, allowing the reader to draw their own connections.
2. Ensure Emotional Resonance: The emotions projected onto nature should align with the character’s experiences. The weather should not be a mere random occurrence but an integral part of the emotional landscape of the story.
3. Use Pathetic Fallacy Sparingly: When overused, pathetic fallacy can become clichéd or melodramatic. Use it strategically to underscore key moments or themes, rather than as a constant tool throughout the narrative.
4. Pair it with Other Literary Devices: Combining pathetic fallacy with other devices like symbolism, imagery, or motif can deepen its effect. For example, pairing a storm with a character’s emotional breakdown can heighten the sense of chaos and foreboding.
Pathetic fallacy is a versatile and evocative literary device that enriches creative writing by linking the emotional worlds of characters with the natural environment. It serves not only to set the tone and mood of a story but also to foreshadow events, reinforce themes, and deepen characterisation. When used thoughtfully and subtly, it can heighten the emotional impact of a narrative, creating a profound connection between the human and natural worlds.
Whether you’re writing a gothic novel, a romance, or a modern-day drama, pathetic fallacy provides a unique way to connect nature to human emotions. By carefully considering the emotional context, avoiding overuse, and allowing nature to mirror the inner lives of your characters, you can harness the power of this literary device to create a more immersive and emotionally resonant story.
Ready to use this literary device in your writing? Take a look at our new courses here!
